Attempt 47. My hands were shaking as I clicked on the Rat Connoisseur again. 🐀
Another mutated meal gone. Another Rhubarb reward. I was about to close the game forever when my friend texted: “One more try, bro.”
Attempt 48. The screen glowed. There it was—that peach-colored butternut squash grow a garden roblox seed I’d been chasing for three days straight. I literally screamed. My mom thought I’d won the lottery. 😅
That 8% drop rate? It felt like 0.0001% to me. But the moment it dropped, everything made sense. The grind. The frustration. The 500,000 coins I’ve made since then.
Let me show you the exact method that finally worked—so you don’t waste 47 attempts like I did.
Why This Crop Made Me 500K Coins 💰
Quick Answer: Butternut Squash = infinite money. Multi-harvest crop. 35K coins per harvest. Never replant. Game changer.
Here’s what nobody tells you about butternut squash grow a garden roblox: it’s not just rare—it’s the ONLY crop that pays for itself forever.
I planted two. Just two. They’ve made me over 500,000 coins and they’re STILL producing. Meanwhile, my friend keeps replanting carrots like a hamster on a wheel. 🐹
This multi harvest crop Grow a Garden changed how I play:
- 35,000 coins per harvest (every 2-3 hours!)
- Zero replanting = zero effort
- Your garden always looks full
- Flex on visitors who don’t have it
The Kitchen Storm Secret (This Is Where I Messed Up) 🌪️
Here’s my biggest mistake: I didn’t know the Kitchen Storm event Grow a Garden was time-limited.
I saw people talking about Butternut Squash and thought, “I’ll get it next week.” Wrong. The event ended. I waited THREE MONTHS for it to return. Don’t be me. 🤦♂️
When It Happens:
Kitchen Storm runs 5-7 days, a few times per year. August 2025 was the first one. If you see the cooking cauldron glowing with storm effects, DROP EVERYTHING and start farming.
How I Finally Got It (After 47 Painful Fails) ✅
The Mutation Farm Trick 🧬
Forget fancy crops. Plant 30 CARROTS in a corner. Just carrots. They’re cheap and mutate like crazy.
Here’s my exact method:
- Buy 30 carrot seeds (300 coins total)
- Spray mutation on ALL of them
- Wait for rain/storm weather (this is KEY!)
- Harvest in 1 hour
I got 15 mutated carrots from one batch. That’s 15 chances with the Rat. This is how I went from failing to winning.
Pro tip: Use Crystals to speed growth. During events, every minute counts! ⏰
The Cooking Mistake That Cost Me 2 Days 🍳
I cooked normal carrots for my first 15 attempts. The Rat Connoisseur Grow a Garden literally said “not interested” and walked away.
YOU MUST COOK MUTATED CROPS. Not regular ones. Check your inventory—it MUST say “mutated” before the food name. If it doesn’t, the Rat won’t even look at it.
This mistake cost me 2 entire days of grinding. Don’t let it happen to you! ❌
The 8% Gamble (And How I Beat It) 🎲
The Rat Connoisseur Grow a Garden shows you 3 random rewards per mutated meal. Butternut Squash seed Grow a Garden appears only 8% of the time.
Math check: 8% means roughly 1 in 12 attempts. I needed 48. Some lucky players got it in 3 tries. RNG is brutal. 😤
But here’s what I learned: the more mutated food Grow a Garden you stockpile BEFORE talking to the Rat, the better your mental game. I went in with 20 meals the second day. No stress. Just grinding.
My strategy:
- Cook 20-30 mutated meals first
- Talk to Rat with zero expectations
- If you see Butternut Squash, click FAST
- If not, next attempt immediately
The Rat location? Right next to Chris P.’s Kitchen (the cooking cauldron). He’s a tiny rat in a chef hat. Hard to miss once you know. 🐀
What I Wish I Knew on Day 1 💡
Mistake #1: I Planted Expensive Crops for Mutations
Wasted 5,000 coins on fancy plants. Carrots work BETTER and cost nothing. Tomatoes too. Cheap = smart.
Mistake #2: I Didn’t Wait for Weather
Storm weather DOUBLES mutation chances. I farmed on sunny days like an idiot. Wait for rain! 🌧️
Mistake #3: I Almost Sold My First Harvest
I saw 35K coins and nearly clicked sell. My friend stopped me. NEVER sell the plant—it’s infinite harvests! I’ve collected from mine over 60 times now.
Mistake #4: I Ignored Event Overlaps
The Moonlight Event ran at the same time. I could’ve done BOTH. Double rewards missed. 😭
The Math That Changed My Mind 📊
Before Butternut Squash, I was replanting 50 plots weekly. 5 minutes each session = 250 minutes wasted monthly just clicking seeds.
After getting two squash plants:
- Zero replanting
- 70K coins every 2-3 hours
- My garden looks full 24/7
According to Roblox economy guides, multi-harvest crops are 800% more efficient than single-harvest. That’s not a typo. Eight hundred percent. 💯
Use the Grow a Garden calculator to track your own profits. You’ll see what I mean.
Fast Track Tips (Wish I Knew These!) 🚀
🔥 Start Before the Event
Grow 50+ carrots BEFORE Kitchen Storm starts. The event won’t wait for you.
🔥 Stack All Boosters
Mutation spray + storm weather + pet bonuses = 3x mutations. I tested this. It works.
🔥 Learn Plant Patterns
Check silhouette guides to organize your garden better. Helps you spot rare crops instantly.
🔥 Don’t Give Up at 20 Tries
Most players quit around attempt 15-20. Push to 30. That’s when luck usually hits.
When that peach-colored squash finally appeared on my screen after 47 failures, I understood why people grind for rare crops. It’s not just the money—it’s the VICTORY. 🏆
The Kitchen Storm event Grow a Garden will return. When it does, you’ll be ready. Plant those carrots. Cook those mutations. Face that Rat with 30 meals ready.
And when you see that butternut squash grow a garden roblox seed in your reward options? Click it like your life depends on it. Because your farming life does. 💪
Screenshot that moment. You earned it. 📸
About the Author:
Zaid Ansari is a Roblox content creator with 400+ hours in Grow a Garden. He specializes in event farming, rare crop guides, and helping beginners avoid the mistakes he made. His Butternut Squash plants are still producing.